Men's Short Sleeve Oxford Button Down Casual Shirt

I hate sizing clothes on Amazon because every other review seems to only address how well the article fit the buyer, and half of the time it's "way too big" and the other half of the time it's "way too small" and privately, I always question how in touch this reviewer or that reviewer is with their own body type and the way clothing is made, how different brands label different cuts etc.That said, this shirt--I've bought many button-up shirts of this type, from many brands such as Gap, H&M, Uniqulo, RVCA, Lee, Levi's, even Amazon's own Goodthreads brand--as well as a couple of these weird-sounding off-brand Chinese companies--this shirt is f****** huge by any standard. I'm 6'1" x 165 lbs US, so I run medium-to-large with most of these companies--I order medium because I prefer a more "tailored" fit and fortunately for me whatever size "medium" is nearly always fits me very well--maybe a little smaller than i'd like.Not so with this shirt though. Man, I measured and the sleeves alone were 1.5 inches wider in diameter than the next-roomiest short sleeve button ups I own--from Lee, which makes pretty roomy medium-sized shirts. As soon as I put it on, i didn't even have to look in the mirror, i knew it was a nonstarter.The thing that kills me is that I could also tell it was a good shirt: The simple styling was appealing. The color was cool. I could feel the decently thick weave of cotton, a pleasing texture that would soften (and yes, possibly shrink a little bit) with time--unlike some other shirts I own. The quality of the shirt seemed to be superior to many of the aforementioned manufacturers including Goodthreads. In other words, the shirt was exactly what i wanted in every way but one, the most important: fit. their "Medium" was borderline XL, easily a "true" large, and far too big for me, when usually medium is too small, if anything. I'm not trying to look goofy. I'm trying to look cool.So now i have to print out a return label and take this thing down to the post office, and I don't have my cool gray shirt. But I hope I can convince you: size down, maybe twice if you're borderline. Or maybe buy from a brand you know works for you. Either way hope this helps

This shirt should be noted as for husky or larger folks. There is no way that the medium we ordered was a medium. My husband was practically drowning in it, especially at the sleeves, and he is a true "medium."

I bought four of these shirts about two years ago in large. They fit actually a bit small than I expected, but I ended up really liking them. It was like wearing a nice fitted shirt. I wear them daily, so they're starting to fade, I figured I'd better buy some more before they're gone and it takes me another 10 years to find a cotton navy blue button-down with button collar and front pocket. Seriously, these things don't exist elsewhere and haven't for ages. Gee thanks Target, no really, I LOVE PLAID. Anyway, so I ordered two more. In large. Just like before. They came, and they were like wearing a freaking tent. I laid my one of my originals over the new one for comparison, you can see in the picture it's much bigger, and that's after a wash to try and get them to shrink a bit! Well, this just didn't work for me, so I sent them back and I ordered them in medium. Nope, still too huge. So I sent those back and got them in SMALL. Yep, that's the one. I used to wear a LARGE and now I have to get them in SMALL. They're literally the same shirt, just one has an L on the tag and one has an S!So be aware, they used to run small, now they run huge. Why do clothing companies do this?

This shirt is A+++ - the fabric is all cotton. The stiching, buttons, collar and sleeve are all but perfect. No loose threads, folding collars or arm sleeves that are too long. This shouldn't matter but the packaging is on point too! Tissue insert, folded, clipped and slipped into a plastic zip top bag which I don't get from Brooks Brother's and I've paid 5 times the price and the quality is just the same! I've ordered my second, this one in a light blue gingham print and interested to see if what I get is the same!

Good quality. Texture just what I like. But one size smaller than labeled BEFORE washing, although it did not shrink during|after washing. No room for undershirt. Because I had laundered it, I gave it to a friend rather than return it.

Nice shirt for the hubs ! It is a bit stiff and definitely needs an iron. I wouldn’t recommend it for warmer months because the material is pretty thick

These are really nice shirts, very well made in the 100% cotton. My only problem is that they fit a little snug and the sleeves are about 1" to 1.5" to short. I will exchange them for a better fit or just return them. I am 5'6" and weigh 150 lbs with slim build. Actual measurements listed would be helpful.

I love a good classic casual cotton oxford button down. I have a few that I have had and worn for so long the collars are finally wearing through. So, I looked hard to find a substantial weight fabric cotton oxford. Much to my delight these looked like exactly what I wanted, and when they arrived, were perfect. The black one seemed to be cut slightly smaller than the green and pink ones I purchased, but still was a great fit. I can not comment on the 50/50 versions, because I don't like polyester blend oxfords. I am very happy with the fit and material of these shirts.

Love these shirts feel so well made they heavy but feel light when on I will be buying more of these

A good quality that fitted as expected.

Really pleased with purchase

Looks good.

La camicia è bella e il cotone solido e un po' grezzo come mi piace. L'unico difetto è che è un cotone spesso e pesante, per cui la camicia risulta calda per essere una camicia estiva