L'oreal Colour Riche Lipcolour, Tender Pink, 0.13-Ounce (Pack of 5)

I had the same problem as others. I bought a 2-pack. One was ok, the other, seemed quite old, even had a sticker saying it was a new color, the bottom color sticker was very faded as well. The real issue is that it has a very bad odor, is wax-like and quite sticky, like glue stick. I can hardly apply it without a lot of effort. The taste is really bad. If I had more time and money, I would have it tested for safety. I can't use it. It may be the price we have to pay to get this color that L'Oreal has discontinued (buy 2 to get one that is useable). I think Amazon should investigate sellers who do this.

This L'Oreal lipstick was sold in a two-pack. It is a discontinued color and I was anxious to find it. One of the tubes smelled rancid and is very hard, which makes the lipstick difficult to apply. The other tube was perfect, fresh, and as good as new. So although I have the color of lipstick I love, I feel like I overpaid for it since one of them is very unpleasant to use.

I really like this lipstick. It does not dry out my lips. This color (tender pink) is really nice for my complexion, I have dark blonde hair, blue eyes, and fair skin. I only gave four stars because it does not stay on that long, I have to reapply several times throughout the day.

The bottom part to twist the lipstick up & down is a bit hard. Other than that the color was exactly what I wanted!

My girlfriend and I both use this color and it is getting hard to find in stores, I bought this for her birthday as a surprise The last one I bought in a store must have been sitting on the shelf for awhile. It was not creamy and had a funny smell.

This is the lipstick that is not pink enough. The color looks pink online.

One of my favorite colors. Hard to find now.

I used this shade quite awhile back and always loved it. It is subtle yet makes an improvement in your appearance (I'm a fair, pink-toned golden blonde). Wish it weren't discontinued!