- Blackout Water Resistant Mascara by Brooklyn & Bailey – Volumizing and Lengthening Formula, Smudge Proof, No Clump (3-Pack, 0.39 oz Each)

LOVE LOVE LOVE! I’ve never had a mascara not transfer below my eyes and lose curl throughout the day before this one. Pictures are before, first day of use done in the car (some clumping but my eyelashes were kinda like that before: see pictures. I also kept trying to fix and then they got clumpier!!!), and today, day 2 (last 2 pictures). I also used an eyelash curler before application today! This is a great mascara. Looked nearly identical 10 hours later. I cried and all they did was get a little clumpy, NO RUNNING OR SMUDGES! Came off very easily with a little of the yellow bottle of garnier miscellar water (the BEST for removing waterproof makeup). Slid off my eyes in a somewhat solid texture with no smear!!! Took maybe 2 minutes to do both eyes. Amazing application, wear, and removal!!! WORD OF ADVICE! DO THIN LAYERS! IT WILL CLUMP IF YOU DO A LOT AT ONCE

The brown shade offers a softer, more natural look compared to traditional black mascaras, which is perfect for my everyday makeup routine. The formula is water-resistant and holds up well throughout the day without smudging or flaking. It's also free from parabens, sulfates, phthalates, TEA, and DEA, making it suitable for sensitive eyes. The mascara applies smoothly and can be layered for added volume without clumping. I appreciate that it's easy to remove at the end of the day with a gentle makeup remover. While it may not provide the dramatic length and volume that some other mascaras offer, it's a great option for those seeking a more natural enhancement.

Blew my mind I have no lashes and it gives me a false eyelash look

It works really well and is very lengthening without clumping. My lashes looked longer and more defined, and it stayed on well throughout the day. The only issue is it had a weird smell, which made me unsure if the one I received was expired or not.

First off, I have never written a review but given how much hype this mascara is given in their IG and the price tag, I wanted to leave an honest review. I had very high hopes for this mascara but feel pretty let down. I love B&B and wanted soooo badly for this mascara to be a miracle fix. The positive I have is VERY positive though. I have extremely oily skin and every mascara I’ve ever tried smudges like crazy on me and this is the only mascara I’ve found that doesn’t do that. Not sure how but it’s quite magical. It also was okay at lengthening. Not great but it did something. Negatives: 1) formula went super thick and clumpy verryyyy soon after getting it and no amount of warming up the tube has helped. 2) It absolutely does not hold a curl. I have Asian lashes (so on straight to the point of downward) so holding a curl is important to me. Curl fell immediately upon application. 3) It’s NOT buildable or voluminous. It took me 3 separate coats to get even close to their lash look and it still wasn’t voluminous. Because of these factors, I cannot, in good conscience, recommend this mascara unless you already face curly lashes (like B&B) and you can layer it with other things. Because I don’t want to waste $20, I now use Maybelline Surreal Extensions on my top lashes which does everything good except has some smudging, and LND on my bottom lashes, and because the lack of smudging of LND is so amazing, I may buy another tube just for my bottom lashes and hope the formula in mine just was a dud and not like all tubes.

I had their black mascara when it first came out and nothing compared now I love their brown mascara too because it’s a bit more natural but still lengthens, maintains curl, anti-clump, is waterproof, and looks fan-freakin-tastic.. imo

MY ALL-TIME FAVORITE MASCARA. It makes my eyelashes so long and beautiful. I get a compliment every single time I wear it, which is quite literally every day. I will tell anyone and everyone about this mascara. I have even bought it as a gift several times. I love that it is water-resistant. It comes off easily in the shower or with makeup remover but it wont if you're crying! Clump-free perfection!

Bought this with high hopes but it takes entirely too many layers for you to even notice it on your eyes. I have to spend about 10 minutes just applying mascara in order to get the finished look. Dont recommend