12 Fresh New York City Bagels (Kalamata Olive)

I was absolutely thrilled to discover I could order NYC pumpernickel bagels. It has been so long since I have been able to locate them anywhere near where I live. These were incredible and very fresh. The aroma drifting from the box as soon as I opened it was so delightful.Update 4/23/2023: Since I wasn't able to eat the full dozen right away I froze 6. I wasn't sure how they would freeze but today I took one out of the freezer and placed it in the microwave for 30 seconds and I was just amazed as it tasted the same as when I received the fresh ones. These bagels are the best!!

Ordered a few New York bagels to try,Arrived in a reasonable amount of time,They were shipped in a regular usps box in a generic peel and close bag. Not sure if this is a cost cutting measure or some weird New York rule….Bagel was good but will not order again due to shipping style.

I got my order of bagels and half of them were moldy!!And you can’t return them!!So I guess I’m just out &40.00!’I will admit ~~ this is the second time I’ve ordered them and the first time they were really good and enjoyable!!So take this review however you want!!

I've missed NYC bagels since I moved south 13 years ago. When I found this offering on Amazon I couldn't order them fast enough and they did not disappoint. Great texture and flavor. While they are not always in stock I keep checking back for when they are. They freeze very well and I keep them fresh in the fridge. You will not be disappointed in these bagels.

Looked like they would’ve been great! Arrived moldy. Picture doesn’t reflect all of the mold spots.

Well, it was a great experience eating these bagels. I sure will do it again.

They were the most important thing in my head for so many years of my life. I never thought I'd see or taste them again and when I saw the pictures of them on your site I couldn't get them fast enough. I wasn't sure they would be the same asI had them in 1972 and when they came from NY I and ate one I was so happybecause they were the ones I had eatenso many years ago. The one that I got was "Everything".It was so soft and chewy . I couldn't get Pat to eat the same kind but the one that is in the store here.I told him that he would love this one from NY and when he got the nerve to have it he couldn't get enough. We went through the box of 15 in about 8 or 9 days. So, I had to go to their website and order more. We decided to try different ones this order. I am so happy Amazon.com has the best of the best of all the ideas that I can get, and you can too.

They are called cinnamon raisin what happened to the raisins. Will not order again