Wayward Lives, Beautiful Experiments: Intimate Histories of Riotous Black Girls, Troublesome Women, and Queer Radicals

One of my favorite authors. I commend her unique approach to presenting information from alternative archives. From a historian’s POV, one may struggle with how Hartman imposes her imagination and narratives upon her subjects. As an academic, the book provides me with rich sociological insights, but is difficult to utilize in my writing. The prose is beautiful and there are so many wonderful and diverse stories that build towards an optimistic outcome. I also loved Hartman’s previous book, Scenes of Subjection, in comparison, this book is an easier read and has a more resolved and uplifting conclusion.

The turn of the century was truly a momentous period in American history. Reconstruction had come to an end, and so too had any federal government investment in realizing the promise of Black citizenship; Jim Crow regimes grew and consolidated their power while extra-legal lynching proliferated. Immigration from Europe, Asia, the Caribbean, and Latin America made and remade race; the fight for women's suffrage continued, and "women's rights" were continually reasserted as something to which only middle and upper-middle-class white women could claim; urbanization pulled folks from the rural areas to the city; the Spanish-American War raged on, and the U.S. empire expanded its reach. And this is only the tip of the iceberg— the turn of the century was a transformative time.In 'Wayward Lives, Beautiful Experiments,' Saidiya Hartman asks us to consider the lives of Black women migrants during this period, those who had fled the racial terror of the South to encounter a different form of racial terror in the North. As Hartman so beautifully puts it, their lives were "marked by negation, but exceed it." So how do we witness the excess? What were their dreams? How and who did they love? What were their hopes? How did they "make do" in the midst of so little? What gave them pleasure? What made them laugh? What made them cry? Did they aspire to motherhood or reject it? When the archival records on these women point us to social workers' case files, psychologists’ evaluations, prison records, trial documents, and sociological studies that described them as *problems*, where do we look to answer these questions (and others)?Hartman has "resisted the tyranny of genre," pushed the boundaries of discipline, and the limits of the archive in this book. When there are gaps in the archive, when the individuals or groups who are the focus live in the gaps themselves, we have to become creative and even more rigorous in our historical reconstructions. Hartman uses deep archival research, literary fiction, music, poetry, and theory from various disciplines to speculate and imagine. I want to be very clear here--this is not a work of historical fiction. Every vignette, every portrait is true. This is a historian's generous offering. What speculation and imaginative readings allow Hartman to do, however, is provide a fullness, an interiority, an agency and autonomy to these women's lives, characteristics that academics, social workers, lawyers, judges, urban planners, etc. denied them. Like so much of Hartman's work, 'Wayward Lives' explores the "afterlife of slavery" in immense detail, and it does so with rigor, care, caution, critique, and magnificent intellect. The text is also a really masterful lesson on method--on how to engage archives, on how to read them, on how to explore, research, and investigate with breadth and depth. It poses a new methodological and analytical framework for current and future historians of "the wayward," the marginalized and the dominated, and encourages us to be bolder and more attentive in our work. Astonishing indeed.

What does freedom mean and look like to Black people?"Everything can be taken from a man but one thing: the last of the human freedoms - to choose one's attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose one's own way". Viktor Frankl"Those who dared refuse the gender norms and social conventions of sexual propriety - monogamy, heterosexuality, and marriage - or failed to abide by the script of female respectability were targeted as potential prostitutes, vagrants, deviants, and incorrigible children". Saidiya Hartman.1890 - 1935 was an evolution, a revolution of Black intimate life. A desire to live life unrestrictive in a new world - The Ghetto. Drunk with freedom, escaping lives of forced servitude. The North became an altered version of the South. The Ghetto, the slum, the tenements is in fact the plantation extended into the city. Black Folks ran from the South to the North hoping for and expecting a form of freedom and a better way of life. There were always laws that were manipulated ad lib to continue to suppress and oppress. North and South were just directions on a map. Black life - poor Black girls unable to or the beholders unwilling to view these Beautiful Lives, these Beautiful Experiments as thinkers or having the capability to contribute anything to better their lives or society. Labeled as criminals and pathology in the eyes of racist, Black Folks would continue to live defying societal norms at every juncture.

This will for me be like Toni Morrison's Songs of Solomon and Alice Walker's Temple of my Familiar a book I will read over and over and each time it will be as if the first. The writing is as dedicated to the scholarly as it is to yhe fiction. Genius in its research. In it I found my grandmother I never met, and revisited my aunt I adored, institutionalized for daring to need to be free. Unfortunately we still have vestiges of the misunderstanding of non white women who dare to be ordinary, normal. Ms Hartman has added to the books written by and about African American women that have been missing. The books we yearn to read but have not been written do we must write them ourselves. The research is aggressive and brilliant. Where there are gaps, she creates the fillers. I thank her for her descriptive prose of the beauty of the the black women then snd now.

Saidiya Hartman has produced a gift of deep love. Her careful attention to the lives of Black women, who society has cast as unimportant, deviant, menial, and forgettable, is both a masterful, poignant mourning and celebration of persistent freedom dreams. This soulful book offers both intimate portraits and a fuller history of the social landscape of the early twentieth-century than typically disclosed. Wayward Lives is a lush elaboration of Hartman's many meditations on what is possible to uncover when the archive is scant and violent.As a writer and student, I am thankful for this book which is a masterclass. As a Black woman, I am thankful for Hartman's commitment to seeing us, caring for us, loving us, and imagining an otherwise.Wayward Lives challenges everyone to take up the work of waywardness, to commit to freedom.

Absolutely wonderful and engrossing read—every aspect of it tries to paint a picture of the lived experiences of the characters within the pages. History isn’t simply about learning from rote—these people lived, loved, laughed, cried, screamed, danced, sang and worked damn hard to survive above and beyond the world’s expectations of who they were, and could be.

I've never read a book that so compellingly charts the journeys of individuals through an an environment marked by violence and social change. There are panoramic overviews of the racial turbulence engulfing early twentieth-century African Americans, but also enthralling excursion into the subjective lives of individuals, captured through diaries and observations. The whole thing is carried by a Baldwinesque evocation of mattresses on fire escapes, street corner scenes, scraps of music and the communal sounds and smells from air shafts. Hartman shows how the ghetto was, on the one hand, held together by the contempt, hatred and fear of the people outside it, and, on the other, a place of personal liberation for people of colour drawn to it from small-town communities in the south. Against the backdrop of a societal macrostructure that restricted and squashed emotions and behaviour, Hartman traces the swerving, unpredictable flights of people determined to be free in their own way. An absolutely enthralling read.

Beautiful, compelling, striking and powerful book, would highly recommend.

Very good