RoyalCare Dog Food Bag for Dog Training with Clip, Magnetic Closure in Silicone for Outdoor Use

Does what it need to keep in there safe and secure on a doggie walk.

Great for puppy training. Easy to clean.

This treat pouch doesn't absorb the oiliness of the treat so doesn't stink like others do! It is easy to wash (goes in the dish washer). It attaches to clothes with a clip so can easily be swapped between garments - mine is on my jeans pocket in the house & then switches to my jacket pocket when going out. No fumbling with belts or buckles! It has been knocked off a couple of times, but only a couple of times despite regular rough play with golden retriever. Also seems durable when pup gets hold of it by mistake - no holes yet! Clips shut with magnet which keeps the rain out & treats in, but doesn't impede the quick retrieval of a treat. This cost me £9.99 but others with very good ratings were £30-40 (which I haven't tried). This ticks all the boxes for me

Love being able to take sticky or moist treats out as my dogs don't get kibble or shop bought treats, and I'd been struggling with trying to line my existing treat bag with plastic pots holding the meat to try and avoid having to put it in the washing machine after every couple of uses. This is so easy and hygenic to clean, it's an inspired idea but it could do with improvement to the clip mechanism. I don't wear waistbands or pockets so I have to tie a cotton scarf round myself to clip it to, and the clip just isn't secure enough. The pouch is nice and wide, and is very easy access, MUCH easier than my other treat bags, and I don't mind that it hasn't got loads of pockets and additional clips for clickers and poo bags because my existing treat bag can hold my phone and keys, bottle of water etc, but considering that this silicone pouch does have just the one single function, it could have been designed more thoughtfully. It could do with a clip on each side so that it can be worn like a cross body shoulder bag or fixed more securely to an 'everything else pouch' because it's not a reliable clip AT ALL and when the treats all fall to one side it becomes unbalanced, puts the clip under strain then it just pings off repeatedly and could be too easily lost. I have tried putting it in a coat pocket but the clip is in the wrong place to allow for it to be kept securely in a shallow pocket either. If it could hang cross body or round my neck as well as being clipped to my clothes, I'd have given it five stars.That said, the magnet closure is great, easy to access a treat with just thumb and forefinger while not spilling any treats (even if you're bending down or jumping about with your dog and it's a brilliant material for ease of cleaning.

I've had this 6 weeks and the clip has just snapped off which is pretty useless. Otherwise the pouch is good for purpose

Brilliant product idea. Good for moist and dry food treats when out on a walk. Easily attaches to belt/trouser loop or fits in pocket of coat. However, admittedly mine are now a year old but, both have broken within days of each other. Plastic clips have broken and spring has popped out. I've managed to attach a carabiner clip to it but the pouch dangles at an angle making it hard to use. Better, sturdier clips required.

I purchased this on recommendation of our trainer and I must say I’m not overly impressed. I usually use my pockets but was sick of all the crumbs left behind so I switched to those fabric ones and found them extremely annoying to get your hand in and out of them without the opening being too big and the treats falling out.This is good to quickly grab the treats and not have to deal with whether the opening is too big or small but I found very quickly that bending down makes the magnetic clasp open and all the treats just pour out all over the floor. The magnetic clasp also tends to fail if you keep putting your hand in and out, the side on the belt clip will turn and stay rolled in so they don’t clip together automatically.My dog being a puppy and still training means he sometimes gets over threshold and jumps up all excited, the clip is very sturdy which is great but as the pouch is silicone and flexible it causes the treats to tip out.The main issue really is the bending down and the treats going everywhere so be careful if you bend down to pick up doggy mess.

==============================================================UPDATE: the clasp is a little bit weak and if you catch the pouch on something (like an arm or clothing) it can break off entirely leaving a sharp spring end behind. I've done this to 2 of these treat holders. Keeping it inside a coat pocket so that the clasp is not used at all is my solution. Dropping one star because of this. Still really handy for dog treats.==============================================================Perfect for dog treats like pieces of sausage. Fits into a jacket pocket or securely onto a belt or trouser pocket. Easy to clean.Beware - if you attach yours to the outside of your clothes and bend down to, say, untangle a dog's hind leg from its lead, a little snout can easily sneak into the pouch and steal all of the bits of sausage.