GarnierMicellar Cleansing Water 13.5 Ounce (Removes Mascara) (399ml) (2 Pack)Compact by Design (Amazon-developed Certification)

This product does remove makeup, but definitely not with one wipe. I will say that my skin is not as dried out as with astringents and wipes, so that puts it a cut above the rest. Will I get it again? Maybe, but I prefer other cleansers still.