MAYBELLINENew York Eye Studio Master Smoky Shadow Pencil, Smoking Charcoal, 0.018 Ounce

I’ve been using this product for YEARS and I’m so sad that it’s no longer in stores and the ONLY option is on here for $25. 😩😭 This was $6 in Walgreens back in the day and worked like magic. Lasted ALL day!Unfortunately, I haven’t found anything as easy to use or clean up as this pencil. Maybelline, if you’re listening…we need this back, please! Please note: I’m only referring to the black color. I’ve used others and they had problems, the blue and purple colors specifically ..:BUT the black…every one was perfect and did its job! I find that applying a little water to the foam brush applicator at the end before smudging makes life easier and the product smudges more uniformly. Like I said before, it lasts all day and doesn’t run or flake. I STILL get compliments. I’ll buy as many as I can before it’s completely gone. 😞

I have used this smoky eyeliner for years. It is a subtle gray, not harsh looking, in fact, just the right amount and goes on smoothly.The packaging was dirty and bent, not very pleasing to the eye. That would be my only complaint.

Love it! The only issue I had is that it fell apart the first time I used it. Still love it though!

This product was disappointing, turned brownish in color instead of black after 2 uses

Best product for soft crayon like for eyeliner

Best ever!

This Blue Blaze eye pencil is a great color, and goes on alright. It's a little stiff, but then some softer ones won't stay on.My trouble with this one is that it takes quite a bit of rubbing and blending to get a smooth coverage, and I don't think that much rubbing is good for the eyelids or underbrow area.I have no problem with oders or fading, so all in all, this is a fairly good pencil.

It's a great pencil. Easy and smooth to apply. Stays on for many hours. I apply it under my eyes and on top of my lids.

... not very impressed, pencil tip broke on the 3rd day of use. mechanical so not sharpenable. Great color, but I not worth the amount I paid for it. Shipping time to Alberta, Canada was reasonable.

Fab product