Full description not available
R**L
Great
Author bravery
B**.
Good history.
Beautiful book to know about Palestine.
S**J
The Palestinian POV - reading in 2023
I bought this book in 2021 but only got to reading it now - in Nov '23 - for obvious reasons. So far, I've had a surface level understanding of this seemingly intractable conflict. This book helps with some detailing - espescially from the Palestinian side (the israeli side has been well covered by media for a while now). Yet, I wouldn't say this is the only book to read on the topic - in fact, the end notes have provided me with more to add to my wishlist. (I would also, for the sake of full clarity, still like to counter-check some Israeli perspective too, no doubt).Despite getting the historical connect of Judaism/Jews with the lands of Palestine/Israel (& a soft corner for it despite being agnostic), I've always also had a sneaking sympathy for the Palestinians' plight - slightly more of late. This book adds to that sentiment. (I'm all for a united democratic state (very tough) or a two state (possible if Israel relents a bit)).In terms of specifics, the description of the 1982 invasion of Lebanon was the one that had me taking particular notice. The parallels with the war happening now as I type is absolutely uncanny (though the provocation seems 'tamer' compared to Oct 7). It remains to be seen if the end is the same i.e. no-significant-movement more or less - hopefully not.The point about the Palestinian political leaders' fumbles in the modern world of diplomacy/lobbying/legalese, makes for sad reading. In the meantime, the Israelis don't update their playbook either with zero compromises.Details of the ineffectual Arab govt response - repeatedly - is an interesting learning. And yet, were they a complete sell out? The psychological support for israel in the west is dealt with and explained but the mid East leaders are all individual nationalism + weaker militaries + beholden to old imperial masters. But surely there had to be the emotional side too. I feel like some mention could've been made of factors like expulsion of Jews from Arab nations (like role of Iraqi govt?) and was this a wise move given that it only increased the israeli demographic game? But i understand that this is mainly abt the suffering of the Palestinian people.The writing is fairly clear. Some aspects of the narrative structuring were a bit confusing and required me to go back to get the chronology of events/motivations right.In short - great for understanding the human palestinian POV; but not the only book to read on this subject.
S**L
Hundred , and counting!!
This was a scholarly work- written first hand and masterfully!Brings together the perspective in the correct focus- of a people done wrong by the powers of an era that beloved it could do it - and then wielding its world hegemony to sustain that wrongs!The book ends just before rte present conflict in Gaza/Israel starts. Waiting to see if this could be the moment of change of this tale of suppression!
�**�
A very informative book!
An excellent book on the history of Palestine and the origins of Zionism and the resistance of the Palestinians against Zionist settler colonialism. A must read.
G**
MUST READ!
Excellent book to read for a thorough knowledge and references. Brilliant page quality! Simply perfect.
R**A
Excellent
Amazon asked me to rewrite my review, and I don't understand why!Anyway, here goes. I am convinced the author has written an excellent book covering the last century of strife in Palestine. After a long time, we have a balanced book that converts the story from a Palestinian perspective. He has been blunt about the failures of the Palestinian Authority, Hamas, etc. However, the story is balanced and well-researched.And yes, it helps us understand the story from a Palestinian perspective without becoming accusatory or emotional.This book is brilliant.
P**P
Starts well fizzles out
Starts interesting but doesn’t sustain the interest
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
1 week ago