Petzos Natural Dog Treats - Canine Cookies, Peanut Butter & Banana Carob Chip Flavored, Gluten-and-Grain-Free Dog Biscuits - Tasty Dog Cookies 10 oz

Edit: 1/24/19I noticed the mold on the bottom half of the bag a day after opening. This would explain why my dog wont touch them and why they smell odd. Threw the bag away.Edit 1/5/19: The recipe for these must changed. They smell different and my dog didnt really care for them anymore. Normally he would gobble these up but this time he just took it and then drop the entire thing on the floor as is. He still goes crazy for other types of cookies so its these treats.These smell really sweet like cookies for babies. My dog is a big baby cookie monster. Perfect combination!

Update 11/19/2018: Customer service is excellent! Not only did they respond right away, they also issued a full refund and send me a replacement plus 2 additional flavors! The product is great, this time it was not moldy - it was probably a one-time situation. Thank you again - our dogs are already looking forward to trying the other two flavors.I received the treats today, 11/14/2018, and opened the bag right away. The treats are moldy! I am so disappointed! I noticed that some of the treats are moldy AFTER I gave a few to my dogs already. I truly hope they don't get sick.

One of my border collies is just not interested in these. She sniffs them, then turns her head away. My othe BC likes them okay, but they are not something he just adores.

These are so hard & my 3 dogs wouldn't even eat them. U gave them to my daughter's pit bulls & they ate them after they sat in their dishes for hours. This was not worth the money & we won't be buying anymore if their products.

My dogs love this product, but out of the 4 different times that I have bought them, three bags have had moldy pieces inside. I used their resealable bag and within a day they were moldy. I found that they must be in a wrapped airtight bag and not the one they came in, and then placed in a container so they do not mold fast. I tried to give them a chance four different times but no luck. I will never buy this product again and the ones that lose out are my little dogs.

Healthy, Pricey but good buy overall

My bully loves the Cranberry/ Blueberry flavored ones the most, but these are a close second! Plus, they are a healthy snack. We definitely recommend!

My dog is crazy about these biscuits. Will definitely buy again.