Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Brown Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof

Oh my God, it's a need. (These pictures are from 3 hours after application with no touching up and even after I have rubbed my waterline with my finger multiple times, (ignore how my eyes look, I am very tired in these pictures lol)) I was very hesitant to buy this eyeliner at first since I have never really had a good experience with any eyeliners being long lasting or smudge proof (on my waterline) and I genuinely believed that this would just be another fake-good viral scam on TikTok. I also had seen so many bad reviews on this (plus positive but the bad ones made me nervous) however I can tell you they are completely false (in my experience). I got the shade Liquorice and wow it is BLACK. Like super pigmented black. It looks absolutely amazing on the eyes and really does help to make your eyes pop. It didn't irritate my eyes at all, the only thing I would say is that it feels a little bit dry once it dries down but it isn't that uncomfortable and doesn't bother me at all. The product is the creamiest eyeliner I've used and glides on EFFORTLESSLY. I will say, it is very easy to make a line too thick or not that sharp since the product is sooooo soft but that wasn't too big of a deal for me as I don't use pencil eyeliners for super sharp wings. I have always had issues with pencil eyeliners on my waterline since I have quite oily eyes so within <1 hour, I have nothing on my waterline anymore and all of it has bled out to the outer corner of my eyes, resulting in a strange blob shape of eyeliner right at the outer corner where your wing would be. It would also smudge terribly and last such a short period of time or be extremely faint by the time I got home. However, this eyeliner is NONE of that. I have currently had it on for 3 hours and it is still super pigmented and none of it has moved from where I have placed it. None of the eyeliner has migrated to my outer corners or around my eyes. The eyeliner does have very very small patches that have worn off but they are not noticeable at all unless you look super close and pull the bottom of your eyelid down to look (and like I said, I have very oily eyes so this is extremely impressive for a product). I highly recommend this eyeliner to anyone who needs a long lasting pencil eyeliner and I will definitely be repurchasing. Very worth the money.

This eyeliner is amazing. I must have tried hundreds and this is the best ! I'll never use anything else. Stays put, doesn't smear, smudge, or 'melt'. I've just been abroad, 28° and 29° some days, it never moved which is a first for me. Can't recommend it too much, Fabulous.

The colour of this is great - black with a hint of silver so didn't make me look too dark! It goes on easily and isn't sticky. I tend to forget I am wearing makeup and rub my eyes a lot, this didn't smudge too much when I did that but it didn't stay in place all night. By the time I got home there was very little left on my lower eye, and it was a little smudged, but the top line was still perfect. I would definitely purchase this again and maybe not be quite so ambitious on the lower level. I have not tried sharpening it yet but I am sure it will be fine

Wow!!! Used first time for standing at a concert. Put it on around 6. Still on and intact at midnight. No running in the corners of the eyes!!! So happy. Easy to apply. Great colour. Amazing price. Ordered 2 more whilst on sale. Not buying another eyeliner brand again

Didn’t fully stay on water eye line, but could see a faint line in places, though I had not put extra on and only applied it the once, o maybe if topping it up after awhile it may of stayed on more. Saying this it is the first eye liner that has actually stayed some what and did not smear. I did test it on back of my hand just to see if I could wipe it off? Nope it stayed on even when rubbing away at it so on parts that have no water contact on application does work very well. Will try on eye line and wait they add more to get a better layer.

I had high hopes for this but unfortunately it is a bit disappointing. I have an Eye of Horus black pencil liner which really doesn’t move at all even after sleep but they only do 3 shades of brown and black and I wanted something equally good. Positives: beautiful colour and pigment, glides on easily and does look amazing for the first few hours. Negatives: it bleeds into the corners of the eyes, especially the inner corner and you end up with eye liner bogeys, as I call them, it also becomes patchy along the eye line itself. I have a much cheaper Rimmel liner which does all those things too and wanted something better.

I've been looking for a smudge proof eyeliner for years! Although this one has very good staying power, probably one of the best I've bought, it does still smudge! Not a lot but it's definitely not as smudge proof as claimed. It can be quite difficult to sharpen, which means a lot of waste so you wonder if it's actually good value for money, however if placed in the fridge, it does help to harden and makes it easier to sharpen. I did search for a good sharpener as well as my old one had seen better days....still on the search for a smudge proof eyeliner!

Goes on lovely and dark on dry areas, probably last around 6 to 8 hours. On the water line it lasted around 4 hours and didn't go as dark. Still a nice soft eyeliner, just not sure its worth the price tag.