4 Real Mascara Black for Volume, Length, and Lift in Eyelashes, Defined & Flutterly Look, Vegan & Cruelty-Free

It has a very short and fine brush that catches all your lashes. It gives a very natural appearance while enhancing your lashes. I would buy again.

This is my new favorite! Not a clumpy mess. Lashes are nice and even and spread out. Looks like a natural look but more enhanced with layered applications.

Best mascara I have ever bought. Love the brush, coats evenly and doesn't leave clumps of mascara. Price is so much lower than other products I don't like as well.

This is a great mascara. It gives my lashes, the perfect length and can build up the volume so easy. It can do little flakes but not frequently enough that I won't wear it. I think it's not a marathon of a day mascara but I don't think any mascara is haha.

I want to preface this by saying I have tried easily over a 100 to 150 mascaras. Everything from Gucci to $3 mascara. I am super picky and I know what I like. That is a thick, bold lash. I want more length than volume but if there is no volume at all it is a hard no from me. So things I like. It's cruelty free, it has castor oil in it. The brush is straight which is my favorite and I find works best for my lashes. The brush itself has lots of bristles that get every single lash. The formula is wetter, which I do prefer. The packaging is really cute. At $14 it's more expensive than drugstore but still on the cheaper end which I appreciate. Overall I really enjoyed this mascara. I have used babe lash products before I find the quality is great. I had high hopes for this mascara and just felt it was missing something. It gives great length but hardly any volume. Even tried it with two different lash primers (Essence and Loreal) and that didn't help much. I feel that it also weighs my lashes down. Any curl they had is gone. I wish I could like it more but there are just better ones out there. It was very easy to move with just water but I also used it with Glossier's milky oil and it came off effortlessly I hardly had to try. It smudge a bit under my eyes throughout the day which I never wear bottom mascara so it was coming from my top lashes so as far as the lasting power. It's pretty weak. If you get raccoon eyes from mascara easily then I would say avoid this. I don't typically have that problem and I did with this one...

Saw this recommended by a YouTuber who i watch, and thought i would give it a try. Before I only used Covergirl mascara, but I now switched to this! Im on my second tube. It gives my lashes a really good length.

I love the way this mascara applies, it has a tiny brush on the end that easily coats those tiny lashes that usually get overlooked, and it lengthens like crazy. The first time I used it I had terrible flaking after about 2 hrs. I thought the mascara was defective so I threw it away. This company has awesome customer service and they sent me another tube. I LOVE THIS MASCARA, no flaking with it at all, long, well defined lashes and no clumping at all, also no flaking. Perhaps I initially got a bad tube or upon further consideration, I had been applying castor oil to my lashes at night, so perhaps I didn't get it all off before applying the mascara and that caused it to flake? No idea, but this is now my favorite mascara of all time!

I also bought this because one of my favorite fashion influencers swears by it. The brush is really uncomfortable to use. Spiky, with short hard bristles. Used it once and it left flakes under both of my lower eyes/lashes. I have never had a mascara flake like this. Back to my trusty old, grocery store mascara.