BBIA Last Auto Gel Eyeliner SLIM 5 Colors – Ultra-Fine Waterproof Mechanical Gel Eye Liner Pencil Smudge-Proof Easy Drawing Smooth Gliding Texture Vegan Korean Eye Makeup (S5 SOUL BROWN SLIM R)

I love BBIA. It lasts & lasts (some people might think too long), and doesn't budge. Best of all, they have lighter colors for those of us who don't like a harsh dark line.

I was excited to use this liner since it says its waterproof and smudgeproof, but it was so hard to apply! They are not lying when they list it as "Ultra Fine", the tip of the eyeliner is chisel shaped and very thin, it glides on smoothly but the tip broke off for me a couple times and so I had clumpy liner in places. It might take a couple tries to get it on right, but it did last all night and once I had it the application down it made crisp lines. removing a star only for the learning curve of how to apply.

I wanted to love this eyeliner, but there just wasn't enough going for it. The tip broke off twice while applying to just one eye, and i barely had it extended. It glides for a little bit, but then just ends up pulling the skin, resulting in very uneven lines. I was truly surprised that it's actually waterproof, so few eyeliners really are. But alas, it smudges way too easily, and starts to run within a few hours. The price point is good.