Eye Enhancers 4-Kit Eyeshadow, silky, sheer formula, double ended applicator, 100% Cruelty-free

COVERGIRL - Eye Enhancers 4-Kit Eyeshadow - Pure Romance I had some hesitation after opening the package and finding such a difference in the shades I received (see photo) and the shades I thought I had ordered. But after scanning the bar code (and trying very hard to read the teeny tiny white printing on a pale pink background on the back) I have come to the conclusion that I did not, in fact, receive the wrong colors. So while I was hoping for mauvey pink tones, what I got, as you can see, was a lot more lavender/purple with gray tones. I considered returning it, but figured since I'd gotten it at a good price, I'd give it a try, if I hated it, I'd pass it along to someone else. Well... to my surprise, I really liked it. The colors are sheer but just pigmented enough that you can put them on and see them on your lids without having to spend 5 minutes with a blending brush to tone down the color. So you can definitely build to the depth and amount of color that you want. The quality is very nice; it looked just as good at 5 pm as it did when I put it on. The colors are soft and creamy and go on easily. I didn't notice any smudging or fading. If it helps, I am fair-skinned with blue/gray eyes and cool undertones, and while I am not normally a fan of purple shades (I am much more comfortable with nude or neutral shades) because they tend to be too bright for me, I don't mind these. I am considering ordering some of the other shades, but hesitant since I don't know what colors I will actually end up with. But other than that, I would recommend them--but maybe check them out in a store first and see how the colors in the picture compare to the real thing.

Great eyeshadow palette with vibrant colors & staying power. Iced it

The first order arrived crushed, just a mess, but the replacement was delivered within 24 hours and was in perfect condition! Thank you! Love the shadow! Gorgeous crystal blue!

These colors are lovely they're very natural. You can use them to enhance your eyes by combining the lighter shades with the darker shades in the crease. They're not expensive and it comes with a lot of different colors and it comes with an applicator. The only thing I'm not crazy about is that the lighter colors don't pop. They're very subtle and no matter how much you put on they just don't have that brightness that makes your eyes sparkle.

Nice quality. I love the color selections but given I haven't worn makeup in such a long time I forgot that light colors do not show up on me very well. I will get it again in some brighter colors. I like that there is some sparkle to one of the shades. I do not use the little applicator but it is nice that it is included.

Mainly ordered this for the black shimmer color. It's definitely pretty, but there's a lot of cleanup involved. I've only used it maybe 5 times (haven't used the other colors yet) and you can see from the picture that it gets everywhere easily even though I go in very lightly with the brush. Speaking of which, there is *a lot* of fallout when applying. Definitely recommend applying this shadow *before* applying face makeup since cleanup will be needed. The black smears when you try to wipe it off your face so a makeup wipe or micellar water cotton pad will be needed to fully clean it off. On the plus side, random fallout during the day actually isn't too bad and even after 8-10 hours the shadow doesn't look faded or smeared. The sticker/seal that holds the case together leaves a sticky residue on the outside when removed before first use. I tried scraping the adhesive off with a makeup wipe but it just got soggy for a bit, then back to sticky 😑 Also would like to point out that the enclosed applicator "wand" doesn't do the trick and the shadow went on very lightly while using it. However when using my own small angled brush, it went on very smoothly and much more pigmented. Just don't push your brush too hard into the eyeshadow or the whole thing will likely crumble. Might order this again despite the issues because the shimmery black is actually pretty and it's affordable. It just seems a bit messy.

The beautiful colors and blendability is smooth and easy to apply. Stays on all day. Love the smudge resistance and the brightness isn’t TOO much. Love the size. You still get a lot of shadow. Great price!

Beautiful colors but more suited for fair skin. The darkest color barely shows up on me unfortunately. I guess I’m still carrying some of my tan from last summer.