Catrice | Pure Volume Magic Brown Mascara | Natural, Buildable, Long Lasting Volume | With Castor Oil | Vegan & Cruelty Free | Without Parabens & Microplastic Particles,

This is for those looking that soft "natural eyelash" look. Is this a super high volume, lengthening mascara? No. But if you are looking for a soft, buildable product that doesn't look clumpy & wet- this is it. My favorite daily mascara/tinted serum was discontinued, so I went on the hunt for a replacement and I think this is it! The formula is a bit dry but it doesn't go on clumpy. AND it has castor oil which was my main selling point. I also like the brown color for a natural look and so many products only come in black. For the price, I am very satisfied.

When I purchased this I was afraid that it wouldn't work out but the color is beautiful!*Edit* Not sure if it's the mascara or the time of year but every time I wear it, my eyes get red/irritated/burn and water profusely. The reason I think it's the mascara is that I don't have the same symptoms when not wearing it. I'll keep trial and error-ing it, really sad because it's such a beautiful color

I’ve had it for several months. I really like the shade, and that it’s easy to remove in water, but I had a few issues with it.My main issue with it is that it makes my eyes burn a little during the first few minutes after application. However that could be that I’m just sensitive to one of the ingredients.It does smudge easily and gives me ‘raccoon eyes’ more than other mascaras I’ve tried. I’m unsure whether it’s because my eyes water from the sensitivity, or the product’s formula.The consistency is a bit more dry and it does come out as chunky clumps on my brush occasionally, but the chunks are easy to remove. Application is easy but the results didn’t really wow me. Ive added a picture of my eyes with and without the mascara.

Sadly, this brown mascara doesn't provide any length or volume to my sparse blond eyelashes.

Firstly, the mascara was not sealed when it arrived so that's a little sketchy for me. But I used it anyway and so far, I haven't lost an eye or anything. The wand is wild...it's too long, in my opinion, which makes application awkward. The mascara itself is a nice deep brown hue that goes on nicely and wears well throughout the day. It's worth a try at this price point.

My second purchase was a fail, no security seal and product was completely dried out

I have used many brands of mascara in my life. and this one, by far, is the best yet.It is creamy, doesn't clump, goes on deliciously, and the color (brown) is perfection. Highly recommend.

This stuff surprised me. It is truly dark brown without looking black at all... Tube says Burgundy brown, but I see nothing burgandy --- just an amazing true rich brown. Love it. Can get a little clumpy if your in a hurry, but I just go for it, build it as much as I want and then clean it up with a spooly. Again --love it.