American ApparelWomen's Heavyweight Cotton, Boxy, Cropped, and Garment Dyed Muscle T-Shirt, Style G307GD, 2-Pack

love this shirt - perfect for dressing up or down. perfect fit. for reference, I'm 185lbs, 5'7 and ordered a large.

Like the oversized boxy shirt, comfortable and good quality. Wish it came in a solid black.

Oooooooh, just opened my package and I’m so excited about this purchase! Definitely going to order more after I submit this review

Haven’t purchased anything American Apparel since about 2009 but got these after I heard an influencer raving about them and she was right. I’ve only had them a week and I’ve worn them multiple times. Can dress them up or down. Great for transition seasons in the south. Fit is great and TTS. I’m 5’4” 130ish lbs and got the medium.

These were so big & boxy. Not flattering at all and I was wanting a baggy look just more fitting in the shoulders. Quality is nice.

I was surprised to see the faded black version is more like a stonewash/dark grey than black. Either way that's totally fine with me, as it's one of the colors I wear the most. From the jump, the fabric is a bit rough, and I lend that feature to the dye, as some blacks can make fabrics (especially cotton) feel a bit rougher. Although, I did manage to get it to soften up in the wash, and thankfully with no shrinkage.I'm 5ft tall, and fluctuate between 117-123 lbs regularly so a small fits perfectly and happy to report it really isn't super cropped, as it falls right at the middle of my hips. If this came in an XS, I probably would've been good with that and still have some room too! Basically it's not long like a regular t-shirt you'd tuck all the way in. For me, it's super cute to tuck it under my bra, for a little belly peek, or tuck the edge into the top of my shorts without looking like a slob as there's not a ton of excess fabric hanging around. I imagine if you are over 5'4", it would probably fall right at or above your hip. Yes it's a bit boxy, but not super square, flows nicely and the tucked under cap sleeve help shape it out a bit more. I like these a lot and wish it came in more than the three colors I see right now. Either way, I may just grab another set of faded black, since it will definitely become a go to comfy tee for summer!

I’m obsessed with this shirt, not only is it comfortable but flattering at the same time. It’s a perfect type of crop top, sits just a tad bit above the waist line (I’m 5’5”, normal size torso)It’s definitely true to size, the color and material is great, this was definitely a good purchase base.

Not too heavy! it's perfect