Peanut Butter & Co. Old Fashioned Smooth Peanut Butter, Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Vegan, No Sugar Added, 16 Ounce

Perhaps not what a Brit would call "value for money", but peanut butter of an excellence that's hard to find. No nonsense: no sugar, no palm oil, not emulsified chemically or otherwise into a runny caricature of peanut butter. Ingredients are peanuts and a bit of salt. The result is tasty, with just enough texture to be substantial. -- (For those new to natural peanut butter: it contains only peanuts and sometimes salt, with no added emulsifiers or sugars. The natural oils from the peanuts separate from the solids, forming a layer on top that requires stirring before each use, a quick easy task.)

Amazing fresh taste and texture....tastes like freshly ground good quality peanuts. This was reasonably priced as well. I will definitely be ordering this again.

I was looking for a healthy peanut butter, one that wasn't half oil, was healthy, and tasted good. Came across this that I hadn't seen before. Ad said it wasn't oily, was healthy and had some good reviews. What a load of crap! This is really I think the worst peanut butter I've ever had. Although I wanted Creamy, they were out so I settled for Crunchy. All they did was cut peanuts in half. BUT, upon opening the box and finding the PB, I could tell it was VERY watery, moreso than I have ever seen before. SO MUCH SO, that when I went to pour the fluid out in the sink, all of the PB came with it so I had to stop. I tried and tried to mix it into the PB but it just wouldn't thicken up. Got a knife full to spread on my bread and it was just water. It just made my bread wet and I couldn't even get it to stick to the knife to take from the jar or spread. You really have a lot of nerve lying in the description. It's not even edible with a spoon. It's disgusting and looks like someone had the runs vs. fresh peanut butter from the jar. DISGUSTING!!!!!!!!!!

This peanut butter came packaged very well and the flavor is excellent! I was expecting it to be less sweet because it's a natural, no sugar added item and was pleasantly surprised by the depth of flavor and thrilled because of the health benefits. Packaging was great and it came perfectly intact, sealed, with no leakage. The only reason I give it 4 stars instead of 5 is because, even after stirring a long time, all the way to the bottom, and each time I use it, the peanut butter is a bit runnier than what I prefer. I expected there to be a separated layer that needed to be stirred in (as I grew up with Costco buckets of natural Adams peanut butter), but this never seems to thicken all the way. Maybe I received a bum jar?

It’s supposed to be oily; that’s the good peanut oil. Just store it upside down & then right side up & stir it up good.

I'm guessing that this peanut butter is made with Valencia peanuts which have a very high oil content.Consistency is very runny; About like thin oatmeal. It will run right off a slice of bread or toast.IMHO, when manufacturers use peanuts that have a high oil content, maybe they should use an expeller to remove some of the oil before grinding it into butter.Flavor is great, but a bit greasy. Maybe it was a subpar batch. If so, quality control issues.

I love my crunchy peanut butter. I've searched many brands of organic crunchy, only to be not satisfied. However, this brand, is by far the best. Not too oily, not too dry, perfect texture. And, it is well mixed with an abundant amount of crunchy nuts. It's the best!

Love this peanut butter! It made the best Keto sugar free peanut butter chocolate chip cookies! Love that it only has 2 ingredients, Peanuts & Salt!