Avon Glimmersticks Waterproof Eyeliner .28g Smoky Grey G05

This is my favorite eyeliner! It's so easy to apply and I love that you can roll it in or out. I don't wear eyeliner as much as I used to, and I haven't even used this in a while, but it's long lasting and still works great whenever I use it. It stays on for most of the day (though beware, gets a little smudgy at times if you have oily skin). It's pigmented but not so pigmented that you're going to get raccoon eyes the first time you apply it. One or two strokes is good enough, but you can keep going if you want it to be darker. I think it's better for eyelid wear, not water-linewear , but it's easy to apply regardless of where you're putting it.

This eyeliner pencil does not go on smoothly! Very rad pencil, would not order again.

It is good. Goes on well but smudges in the corners after wearing.

It was totally empty. No eyeliner in it at all

Stays on during the day. Might have to reapply if going out that night. Goes on easily. Doesn't last as long as a regular pencil, but the ease and no sharpening is worth it.

I usually get these from Avon directly I love them.I purchased this and it was different. The entire pencil came apart from the wand and I had to press really hard to see the color. Something that does not happen when I purchase from Avon directly. I contacted the seller and was given a replacement at no charge ( very nice of them) but alas, it was exactly the same.

The very best eyeliner ever. Goes on smoothly & doesn't make my eyes water!

I usually love these sticks but this one is smudging. I've been using them for years and they have never smudged. It is nice and creamy but a bit too much comes off, not like the brown/black I have. Hopefully it's just this one stick. It still lines the eyes and makes them stand out, but don't sweat or rub your eye or it's all over the lid and your fingers. If you can keep fingers away, it's four stars. The color is nice, too. I might buy it again to try same color, but another stick.