Maybelline New York Master Precise Ink Metallic Liquid Liner, Black Comet, 0.06 Fluid Ounce

This is the only liner I can use. I originally got the light lavender/silver at the dollar store when they had them for a while and I loved the fact that it was so easy and comfortable to use. Plus if I messed up I only had to wipe it away with my finger. I’ve also found that the best way to take it off it to get a q-tip wet with warm water and just twirl it on my eyelid where the liner is and it comes off immediately. I was nervous to buy this black because it’s a more intimidating color to use, it doesn’t just wipe away, but it’s so easy to use. The felt tip is awesome and doesn’t spread like the brush tips. I also like that it has a hint of sparkle and isn’t just flat black.I also love that it is waterproof (and funeral proof) so I just kinda put it on and don’t have to worry about it again!

If you shake it really well, it comes out a gorgeous gold color and stays on all day. I always have an issue with eyeliner staying for long since I am a fairly active person and they usually tend to start bleeding or smudging throughout the day. This literally stayed put where I put it as my black started to fade downwards. As a Note… I have very sensitive skin so have to be careful with what I use. This caused no irritation or redness until I went to remove it. Only left a slight pinkness that went away pretty quickly (10-15mins). Not a huge issue so will continue to use it and will probably try some of their other colors.

Think they may be discontinuing this product. A total shame:'(The teal is one of the prettiest colors I've seen and the purple is just gorgeous- both are so vibrant. It stays on well and not difficult to remove. Have gotten many compliments on it. I bought a couple of these before and nearly fell out of the chair seeing it has jumped to $45.So sad to see this go😭.If you'll pay 45 bucks for it, you won't be disappointed. I will just not have my beautiful liners anymore😪

I was under the impression this is supposed to be a gold eyeliner. I still think it might be, but may be very old and dried out and/or seperated. In the pictures there is some white chunky stuff and a few specks of glitter on the applicater. Looking down into the bottle all the way at the bottom I could see some gold. However no matter how much I shook the bottle or wiggled the applicater around inside there, I couldn't get anything else to get on the applicater. Swatching on the back of my hand only resulted in a result of what appeared to be nothing.

First off, I think this eyeliner is pretty solid. It's not as metallic looking as I'd hope for, but it goes on well and stays on ALL day. As others have mentioned, I too notice that it feels a little weird - like it's sufficiently thick that I can feel the eyeliner on my eyelids, which can be a little weird to get used to. It doesn't irritate my skin, per se, it just feels weird. It's still my go to eyeliner of late, but if you make a mistake putting it on, fix it/wipe it *quickly*, as once it dries, it's not going anywhere without some work.

3 stars for actually being skinny eyeliner pencils that went on easily even on my aging eyes...however i wanted to really give them one star for falsely advertising that these are all day/24 hr liners when both (i bought black and a charcoal one) literally disappeared off my lids within 2hrs max, at least that is when i went into bathroom and saw that the liner on top and bottom of my lids was mostly gone and what little remained in odd areas looked smudged, as if i rubbed my eyes but, i do not rub my eyes! it didn't bother me much but, it also would not go on the inside of my bottom lid part from the start, just acted like oil does with water and would not stick to lid. if i hadn't bought these straight from A, i would think they were not authentic that is for sure.. guess back to melting and using the old trused maybelline red eye pencils version, at least those lasted longer and went on inside lid part!

My favorite because it’s easy comes off well good price

I had been looking for an affordable (and decent quality) eyeliner and I stumbled across this one and love it. Throughout the day, it doesn’t transfer to other parts of your eye, it stays put.