MaybellineNew York Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil Eyeliner - 911 | Smooth Walnut

Great eyeliner. Stays put all day.

Nice colour.... Not too dark or light.. Nice and soft not harsh

In my quest to find a smudge-proof and waterproof black eyeliner for my upper and lower waterlines I read the reviews and thought this would be worth a try. It’s a difficult one because it has stayed on, it hasn’t smudged and it is waterproof but it’s made my eyes water all day, even writing this nearly 12 hours after applying. So it does what it says on the tin but I suffer with dry eyes and think it’s aggravated that. Shame because it glides on easily and has a strong black colour, exactly what I was looking for. I’m going to persevere and see if my eyes adapt, fingers crossed. If not it’ll be another one in the reject pile and the quest continues.

very good, quite a generous size for a pencil eyeliner. waterproof until you start to rub it. soft eyeliner makes it have an easier application. durable although occasionally it would get stuck in the lid and the end part would snap off but the liner is still usable. recommend highly

Good value for price. Colour is a rich, deep black. Does not glide easily, can be a bit difficult to apply and get accurate lines(especially for those who haven't used a gel eyeliner before). Functional, with a smudge brush on the other end. Easy to sharpen.

Only eyeliner I’ve found that stays on all day

very good waterproof. doesnot smudge and it lasts for very long time.

The eyeliner is great, until you use up the initial tip and you have to sharpen it. I tried various sharpeners and nothing works, the gel pencil keeps breaking in the sharpener. It is very frustrating as it seems to me that I have purchased on a one time application product and I can’t use the rest. Very disappointed.