All Flavor Gourmet Saltwater Taffy (Banana, 2 Pound)

Before ordering I checked out the reviews, and I was skeptical. I really didn't want to receive poor tasting balls of gooey taffy but, since I really wanted the taffy, I figured I'd give them a try (worse case is about $20 wasted). I AM SO GLAD I GAVE THESE A CHANCE! I ordered 2lbs all Chocolate. They arrived in 4 days, no goo balls, not sticking to the wrappers, and tasting very fresh! Yes, they are smaller than the taffy candies I remember getting years ago but, it is 2024! I like a very strong chocolate flavor - I would say these are medium but I'm happy because it's a good chocolate/taffy mix. These are not overly expensive at today's standards, and are, of course, not top of the line 'Gourmet' but, for the $$ & the flavor, I think they are perfect! The last time I purchased taffy I bought it at a Candy Store (supposed to be made on the premises) and it was AWFUL - these are much better! I will certainly order these again.

I received the sugar-free saltwater taffy and it was in good condition and they taste really good. You would not know they were sugar-free. The flavors are mint, vanilla, cinnamon, chocolate and one other flavor That's good but I don't exactly know what it is. If I wasn't on a weight loss diet I would buy them again.

I have something of an iron stomach. I could dig out a three month old half-eaten double cheeseburger from under the seat of my car, use a chisel to break that rock into bite sized pieces, and then wash those down with milk that's about four days past the expiration date and never look back on this with any digestive discomfort or questioning of my life choices.But these... these candies... were made in a special place in Hell. The arrive nicely packaged and pretty and pastel and for people like me who are trying to curb the sugar in their lives, they seem like perfectly wonderful little ventures into Wonka's factory. It is a lie. A deception of the highest and most sinister kind. You eat one, two, and before long a handful...And then it happens... A little innocent toot here, a whistler there, and then, cramps to rival that final scene from Braveheart where they disemboweled Mr. Wallace while he fought every moment not to let out a scream of agony. But you will. You will moan, you will twist and contort into unnatural positions that will make you consider whether or not you have a future in a sideshow. And before long, you'll know that you can wait no longer. The rest of your night is best spent cautiously perched upon your porcelain throne because you never know if that forty-seven second fart rippling the water below you will end with a violent outburst that borders on being classified by the the UN as a war crime. You'll get no rest, because you'll be afraid to sleep.And then you'll wake up the next day, confused, unsure if it was really these pretty little candies that did it to you. You'll review the entire previous day's menu and think, "Maybe it was that Chinese stir fry?" or "Maybe those chicken nuggets I sneaked when nobody was looking were a little bit off?" So you'll do it again on day two, just to be sure. And then it will start again, one inconsequential little toot, and you'll know, these things need to either go straight into the trash or into the candy dish at work that sits on the desk of that prick you just can't stand working for.

I love salt water taffy. This taffy looks delicious. It isn't necessarily bad taffy, the flavors are not very distinct.I had one piece that looked like maybe leftover bits all put in 1 piece. It tasted pretty yuck. The others aren't yucky but it is difficult to tell what the flavors are. Most taffy has a pretty distinct flavor profile. These seem either very subdued or just muddled.I will try a different brand next time.

These are so yummy! I ordered the sour blue raspberry and they get more sour the more you chew into the middle. I love buying these for gifts and myself!

very soft and most colors have the same kind of marshmallow cream taste. i'd bought 2lb of blue raspberry previously which went nice and hard the way i like them but had a strong tangy persisting flavoring. the solid blue ones in this pack taste like marshmallow cream. the purple ones taste like grape, watermelon and banana are there and i can detect an orange cream flavor but they're all kind of half strength. sorry to say it.

I ate the whole bag with my husband and we loved every bite of this cinnamon saltwater taffy. If you like or enjoy cinnamon this is a must! I would purchase a bigger bag next time if available.

Didn't take long to ship. Nice appearance. Tasted odd/old. Tastes like they had been on the shelf a long time. Texture is too soft. I won't buy this brand again.