K&H Pet Products Stock Tank & Pond Heater, Ultimate Stock Tank Deicer w/ Cord Clip, Water Trough Heater for Horses, Cattle and Livestock, Full Cage, Floating, Submersible, Safety Listed - Red 500W

UPDATED REVIEW 9/18/15:IMPORTANT NOTE: DO NOT USE SUBMERSIBLE AQUARIUM HEATERS OUTDOORS IN A FARM/BACKYARD CHICKEN SETTING - FIRE HAZARD!!My original review was not favorable of this device. I have had more experience with it now that changes my view to very favorable, in fact I have revised my star rating from 4 to 5 stars.My usage and background info: I am using this in a 5-gallon plastic bucket with horizontal chicken watering nipples in a backyard chicken setting. We have no other poultry than chickens. I live in the inland Northwest USA, where winters are pretty cold. Average winter temps are about +15F at night and the coldest I have tested the K&H de-icer is down to -9F (it works, with one important caveat).My original review said it would not keep the nipples thawed and I switched to using a submersible aquarium heater. What I have learned since then:* The K&H does not work with VERTICAL chicken nipples (these install on the underside of a bucket/container/pvc pipe) below +18F.* The K&H works great with the HORIZONTAL chicken nipples (these install on the side of the container). I have tested down to -9F and others have confirmed down to -20F, using the same nipples and de-icer).* The horizontal nipples only work with chicks and chickens, won't work with ducks/geese but probably will with turkeys or other birds.* A submersible aquarium heater IS NOT SAFE TO USE OUTDOORS AND MAY START A FIRE (more below on this).For a good discussion on the differences between the Vertical and Horizontal chicken nipples (with photos), try this link: http://www.backyardchickens.com/t/843040/vertical-gravity-vs-horizontal-spring-loaded-watering-nipples . If the link does work, then go to backyardchickens dot com and search for "vertical vs horizontal nipple" and you will find the thread discussion.About the fire danger: the short version is a submersible aquarium heater nearly started a fire in our chicken coop when the bucket ran dry. The K&H is *designed* to handle being run dry (water runs out, container leaks empty or an animal trips on the cord and pulls it from the water, etc). I have pulled the K&H from the water and it shuts off (in a few minutes it is cool to the touch)...put it back in the water and it turns on again (pull it from the water and it is too hot to touch). The submersible aquarium heater also is *supposed* to have a safety feature that will turn off the device if no water is present. I came home one day after having been out of town for a few days to find the bucket with less than 1/2" of water in the bottom. The aquarium heater element was exposed, sizzling and had melted one of the suction cups AND PART OF THE BUCKET. For me, this was just too much, too close of a call, to continue trusting the safety of this device. Yes, I should have been more careful or used a bigger bucket to not allow the bucket to run empty, but this would never have happened with the K&H. I know there are a lot of folks out there using submersible aquarium heaters and have not had any issues with fire...yet. It is Russian Roulette to do so, if you ask me. For the same or slightly more price (I paid $3 less for the aquarium heater I had used for a short time), you can get this K&H de-icer, which was designed SPECIFICALLY for outdoor/farm use. I'd hate for you to lose all your chickens (and maybe your home, too) because you saved a couple dollars.For those of you who are balking at the 250W (or higher) rating of this device over the 25-100W of an aquarium heater: Unless you are on a solar-powered setup, it won't matter much. The higher wattage simply means it will take less time for the device to heat the water. For example, it might take 10 minutes for the 250W device to heat the water to X degrees, but it might take 2 hours for the 25W one to do the same thing. Which one uses less electricity? In this case, the 250W device uses less. Also, since the 250W device is not operating as long of a time, it will better protect the internal components from wearing out prematurely...meaning your investment should last longer than with a lower wattage device. This is all hypothetical and of course it would depend upon your exact climate/circumstances to better determine how a particular device would work for you. But if the fire danger doesn't sway you from the aquarium heater, perhaps the reality that it probably is going to use less electricity than you think, will.Other thoughts: If you are considering this K&H device from Amazon, wait until Autumn to purchase it. At least for the last 3 years, I have noticed that in the Autumn the price drops about $10-15 and a free shipping option becomes available. In summer time, shipping is an extra $10+ and the price is another $10-15 higher.Notes on the included images: This is my chicken watering winter setup. The Reflectix (aluminized bubble wrap) is unnecessary. I used the bucket setup without it the first winter, which was actually colder than last year. I added it to try to use perhaps a bit less electricity. The brick on top is simply to hold the lid on better, as it is not the correct lid for this bucket and doesn't snap on tight. I suspended the handle of the bucket (the bucket rests on cinder blocks) simply to act as a deterrent to the chickens roosting/pooping on the bucket (it works well for this).ORIGINAL REVIEW (circa 2013, aquarium heater NO LONGER recommended):It keeps the water in the bucket thawed, but the nipples would freeze when it got below 12F. The bucket was hung in a fairly well protected from wind spot. Switched to a 50w submersible aquarium heater, problem solved. It does keep the water very warm compared to the K&H deicer, but at least our chickens don't get stuck with no water access.IMPORTANT NOTE: DO NOT USE SUBMERSIBLE AQUARIUM HEATERS OUTDOORS IN A FARM/BACKYARD CHICKEN SETTING - FIRE HAZARD!!

I purchased this stock tank heater a few months ago and have been very pleased with its heating element in extremely cold below 0° Temps! It does have a cage on it to protect against damage to your stock tank. I am using in a 100 gallon rubberized stock tank. The water has not frozen even on the coldest nights! My horses are drinking more water this winter then they ever have.

Couple challenges with these---floating is problematic. I recommend you pull the floats and let them sink. They like to flip over and be weird.They also have no way to know if they're in water---so if your water level gets low, they just run at full power half in / half out of the water. Not sure how long they're going to last since they've got crusted on goo from trough water where a piece of the element got exposed and cooked.

I bought two of these (1500 watts) last year only after cold weather had already hit and figured I would never get to use them. Then last week ice, sleet, snow and severe cold (0 degrees) and temps not going above freezing all week hit our deep Southern community. Doubting they would even work to keep my two 180 gallon water troughs from freezing, I skeptically went ahead and installed both late one night and plugged them in. I was AMAZED the next morning when I checked the water, and the troughs were completely free on any ice. What a timesaver for me and a lifesaver for our cows! Excellent product! Highly recommend!

Put in tank over weekend & water in tank has frozen 3 nights. It's been 40 or above each day & around 28 at night. Currently 30 degrees & 9:30 pm but water already frozen on top & unit was frozen in water.Put 1 last year too & it didn't work this year. Can't afford to this

i cant not give a good review because it does what it says, but i tried to use it to keep my plunge tub (100 gallon stock tank) from freezing completely in the Ohio winter, and even though it has been well below freezing at night it has kept my tank warm. if submerged the whole tank would be around 60 degrees which defeats the purpose of the cold plunge. When i floated it only the first few inches would be warm but 6 inches or so below the surface it was still pretty cold so it will get me by for the winter, which i imagine is perfect for livestock but not great if you are trying to keep something just above freezing.

Unlike most stock tank heaters this one does not have a thermostat and does not shut off! The water in the tank got really hot! It was steaming! Almost too warm for the animals to drink.When the water level got low it melted the plastic and foam all through the water!Seems to be a safety risk. I will not be using this again next season.Works in a pinch but monitoring it closely is highly recommended!

It is keeping the water from freezing (the coldest it has gotten so far has been 9 degrees Fahrenheit/-12 degrees Celsius). It’s nice not having to worry about the animals having water while I’m at work.I highly suggest getting the model with the float. If you don’t want it to float you can remove it but you can’t back up and buy it separately. I really like the cord clip to keep the critters from messing with it.I have a 6.5 Gallon “LITTLE GIANT® DURAFLEX ALL-PURPOSE RUBBER TUB“ for the goats and was having a hard time picking a heater because they all say they’re safe for plastic or metal but none specify rubber. So far I’ve had no issues.I got the version with the float specifically because I didn’t want the heating element to touch the rubber just in case it would cause an issue.

Purchased this de-icer for an outdoor water trough. I decided to purchase one which is one size bigger than I required and it's working well so far. No freezing in the 40 gallon water trough for the pigs. Will update review if there are issues when the temperature drops to -30 degrees celcius.The design is great. Very easy to change to a sinking deicer if required. Very good for the price.

So far so good. Works to keep the stock tank clear of ice. Although our winter has been quite mild for Alberta Canada so far. We have not had any weather below -10°C since having this heater. And can’t speak to longevity, as it’s only been a month.

I ordered this & after plugging it in to my horse tank , the plastic melted . When I purchased it I assumed it was made of metal ! There are all steel deicers that are all steel for cheaper . Wish I knew . What’s interesting the posting does not say it’s made of plastic . Otherwise I would have never bought it .. :(P.S. product is very expensive in comparison .

It froze up and the company and Amazon were both great at arranging a replacement

one works fine, the other in less then month has stopped working !