Jersey Pickles - Sour Pickled Tomatoes (Half Gallon) – Pickled Vegetable – Handcrafted Gourmet Tomatoes for Sandwiches, Charcuterie & More

Most incredible pickles and tomatoes I’ve ever had! Love the dill, sour, hot tomato and sour tomato. Can’t wait to try more!

I’m writing this review because, at this point, it feels like I’m trying to catch the dragon. I ordered the sour tomatoes a couple of months ago, and they were an absolute 10/10—delicious, crunchy, and everything I hoped for. Well, I’ve tried to order them three more times since then… and every time, it’s been a disaster.The first attempt? The tomatoes arrived warm, soggy, and soft. I’m not sure what was happening there, but it wasn’t what I was hoping for. The second attempt was even worse: they arrived leaking and damaged, and I couldn’t even risk eating them due to concerns with food safety.By the third attempt, I thought, “Let’s go big or go home” and ordered a gallon of sour tomatoes. Big mistake. The tomatoes arrived leaking through the box, and someone had decided to "fix" the broken seal by slapping on some shipping tape (because that’s totally how you want your food sealed, right?). And since there are no refunds, I’m now stuck with $50 worth of green tomatoes I can’t even eat.Jersey Pickles, I really want to love you, but at this point, you’re making it rather difficult.

Tried these in Pittsburgh and loved them.

I was expecting them to be crunchy. I have seen many people eating these on social media and theirs were crunchy. The one I received were very mushy and I did refefrate them for hours before trying. I must have got a bad batch? Super unfortunate do to the high price after shipping. I was looking forward to these.

I must’ve written at least a half a dozen favorable reviews for these tomatoes. I hope I don’t get in trouble, but I save the brine and add cucumbers and pepperoncini and what not to it and I pickle just about anything using the remainder of the pickling liquid.

These pickled tomatoes are life. I absolutely love them. I’m a big pickle person and I saw a review in one of my pickle groups that I’m in on Facebook and I was like well let me go ahead and try. They are a little bit pricey, but you gotta think about it. That’s a lot of tomatoes OK so the price was worth it I was trying to diet and stuff and if I got hungry, I would just have one of these tomatoes and oh my gosh they are so filling I highly highly highly recommend you really don’t know what you’re missing out on!

These are terrible. Had no flavor at all. The juice is great so I don't know why the tomato has no flavor. The hot ones are 10/10

These are so delicious