Pet Craft Supply Freeze Dried Dog Treats and Cat Treats - Naturally Wholesome Grain Free Single Animal Source Protein Rich Treats

My dog went crazy for these, and he is VERY picky with treats, so overall these are a good value and I'll probably buy them again. They do have a bit of a pungent smell, similar to what I've noticed before when chicken dog treats include organ meats like liver. However, I think that probably makes them healthier for my pup, and the smell is definitely enticing to him, so not a problem at all, just something to note.

I could not comment on the taste since I don’t eat them, but my dog seems to think they taste pretty good. I use them to get her to do things I want her to do.

Although my dog loves these treats. He only had about 3-4 and threw up. He’s only 8lb so that’s strange considering I’ve givin him a lot of different kinds of treats. This is the only one that made him sick. Hm.

What I really like is that they hold together for a treat. You do not want to have it fall apart just getting to it or transferring to a biscuit container. Excellent processing practice. Furthermore, my dogs go crazy for it even as puppies. I feel safe, confident of ingredients, and the quality. If dogs could talk, I am certain they would ask for it by name. In the meantime, standing exactly where this treat is stored is a pretty clear sign they got it right.

My dog loves these, but they smell disgusting to me. Every time I open up the bag, I throw-up in my mouth a little bit. I talked to my partner about it, and he doesn’t mind the scent nearly as much as I do – it smells fishy to him, but doesn’t make him nauseated. So, he’s the one who is giving these treats to our doggo. It’s a no for me. Won’t buy again. If you aren’t sensitive to smells at all, you’ll probably be fine and your dog will love these! But if you are, it’s probably better to try another treat option.

I really like feeding these to my dogs because they love liver. I got one package and saw how much they loved itso I came back for more. I make liver "brownies" for them and although they are nasty smelling to me and disgustingto make all four of them sit in front of the oven while they bake. (I go outside to garden while it bakes!) Since I donot make these on a regular basis these snacks are well liked by all four of them. I like these because they are in cubes and I have had some that are irregular pieces. It is easier to tell how much they get this way. my dogs highly recommend this product!

Oh boy do these stink like fish. When your dog trainer, who has trained 100s of dogs, comments that these are the stinkiest treats she's ever encountered, you know you've got something special.My dog LOVES these, as did other dogs in our class (def sent this link out). We use it as a high value reward and it really gets his (and everyone's) attention.My dog is on a beef, dairy, and chicken-free diet, so you can imagine how hard it was to find a high-value treat that is free of those but more than a peanut butter biscuit. Super pleased with the simplicity of ingredients and canine palatability. Will def be recommending, and purchasing more.

My Cat Loves This!Missing a star for quality because the first bag I received was mostly powder. I discovered that my cat loves and will eat the powder too. My cat loves this so much, shown by even eating the powder, that I ordered a second bag even though there was a lot if powder in the first. The second bag came looking much better with hardly any powder. I recommend for cats!

I received ashes instead of salmon 😱