Organic Valley, Organic Fuel High Protein Milk Shake, 20G Protein, Chocolate, 11 Fl Oz (Pack of 12)

Why did they change a good thing? I was ready to start subscribing to get these shakes regularly but then they changed the formula. How do I get the old stuff again?

They took away most of the calories and made Organic Fuel a dieters product. What a bad mistaken change to come to a formerly great product..

Amazon replaced my standing order for Organic Valley 's original Organic Fuel (which I love) with Organic Valley's new product labelled Fuel (which, incidentally, has less protein than the original). I took a swig of the new product before reading that it has 50% less sugar, but my first taste told me it contains stevia (if I'd known this I wouldn't have accepted the replacement product). Unfortunately I received a pack of 12, but they will be my last!

So I get wanting to reduce the sugar in something, but the new taste is just awful. They shouldn't call is "chocolate" flavor, because is simply isn't. More like chalk or cardboard. What happened?? I love you old drink, and now I can't find it. Please bring it back.

What attracted me to the previous version of this product was it's exceptional taste. The flavor was awesome, and it tasted natural - like milk.This new formulation completely messes up the taste. It it chalky/gritty, and tastes synthetic - like other disappointing products in this protein shake category.I have to wonder if they did any focus groups with actual customers before launching this new version of the product.. If they had, I can't imagine they would have proceeded to swap the old product for this new version.

The old chocolate flavor was perfect. I understand that some people will prefer less sugar but for me, the Stevia leaves a bitter aftertaste for hours after consumption. I also prefer to have the extra 6 grams of protein. Why can’t both products be offered? I have been buying this product for over a year but I will not purchase again. Very disappointing. I have tried several other products but I did not like the taste until I tried Fairlife Nutritional Plan High Protein Chocolate Shake. This Fairlife product also contains Stevia but they have managed to make it taste good! 30g of protein, 2g of sugar and 150 calories. Perhaps, I can save you some time and money by recommending that you try the Fairlife product before you try something else.

When I bought these I just assumed they changed the packaging and not the drink. My kids would have one a day on the go on the way to school. I guess you are calling it "old chocolate" that is now not available. They hate the new product. Both kids have tried it more then once and hate it. No have two cases that I guess I will just have to find a charity that want's them.

Your browser does not support HTML5 video.  I don't know what the hell happened here. I paid extra thinking I would get something delicious like I normally do from organic valley, but this was like sucking a glob of turd. How do you know if you're ordering an organic valley shake that tastes like chocolate milk, or like tar? I don't understand how to purchase responsibly. It feels weird to show up at Kohls with a bunch of protein shakes and try to return them since the box was already picked up by recycling, but I'll be damned if I didn't just pay $28 for bottles of slime. I'm a bit concerned that blob in the sink is about to come alive and attack me. I've named it Kurt. Let me go see if it's still there and if it moved towards the drain. Hopefully it hasn't moved away from the drain. Looks like Kurt is slowly moving towards the drain. I took a photo about two minutes after I did the squeeze video. I really don't know that I can describe to you just how bad this is. First of all, I'm a big texture person, and something went horribly wrong with the texture here. Second of all, the taste was awful.