4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara & Eyeliner Black Set, Liquid Extension, Best for Eyelash Thickening & Lengthening, Long Lasting Waterproof, Natural Non-Toxic Hypoallergenic, All Day Luxurious Natural Look

This mascara is Ok. It has the fibers, but they kinda just go all Willy Nilly like and seem to flake easy. It does clean easily at the end of the day, but I’m not sure I’ll purchase again. The eyeliner is ok, goes on smooth, but seems to “crack” easily once dried. It also wipes of pretty easy with a makeup remover wipe. It does hold all day though, and I’m one of those oily skin types that ends up with the weird black goo in the corner of my eyes. This stuff doesn’t do that, which is nice. I’ll continue to use it until gone, but I will probably end up buying something else next time.

Liked how the mascara worked on my lashes

I got this product and I used it a couple of times. The eyeliner didn't create smooth lines, and the mascara got pretty dry.

Great! It extends my eyelashes. I have eyelashes that aren't noticable and this mascara gives it a little extra boost. I also love the eyeliner. Great buy. Will buy again.

Looks pretty, goes on thick, great

This mascara works awesome. I had previously paid almost $20 were the same mascara on a different website and so you can’t beat the price. It is very waterproof as I work in water all day and it has not run or smeared at all. However, it is not hard to get off. It is amazing and I will be sticking with this brand from now on!

Great product for the price. Love the deep black color. Wears well.

I can't believe how amazing the mascara is. Fans em out. And my eyeliner is waterproof