Waterproof Lip Liner Pencil, Pack of 12

I'm a pro makeup artist and these are a MUST in my kit! The color range is great, although the range is on the warm-neutral side, some colors that look like they will be cool aren't. Overall, comparable to NYX pencils in texture and wear time but the price point is amazing! Will swatch and add picture later :)

The colors are labeled differently but when I line my lips each one was very similar in color. The darks came out to a light reddish color and the product does not stay on. Smeared off just as fast as I put it on. Don’t wast your money on this product.

My daughter ordered these lip liners with a gift card she received for her birthday. The set that arrived had 4 colors and 3 of each color. I contacted seller and they resolved the issue by sending another set. The set sent the 2nd time was all different colors and sent rather fast. The liners are not waterproof as the package claims. The pencil colors do not match with actual product. Final thought: for the price they are buttery feeling and non drying for my lips. Good lip liner for the price, great for teens testing new colors, or anyone.

Love these lip liners! They arrived way sooner than expected. The only reason I don't give it 5 stars is because some colours are slightly off from what is shown, but not by too much. But hey, I'm not complaining for the price, I'll still wear them all. They feel light on my lips but are very pigmented. They're not as waterproof as id like but then I just use no smear lipstick and it's fine.

I purchased this because I wanted to experiment with lip colors to see what I liked for my skin tone before investing in "quality" lip liners, assuming this wouldn't be great at such a low price, but I actually really loved them! They have the right amount of creamy where they apply softly without bleeding everywhere. A few of the colors are similar, but not so much that I feel like I don't have a good amount of options. The only thing I was disappointed with was the one with the plum color top (055) because it was more of a red berry color than the purple I hoped it would be. But other than that, I have no complaints. They even arrived early that expected. I would buy them again.

I'm not a big fan of these lip liners. They arrived fast enough and the packaging was decent but I had some issues with them that was really disappointing even for the price.First main issue is with the colors. They are much lighter than expected when you wear them opposed to the color shown on the caps and picture. I had a really hard time matching these colors with any of the lipsticks that I own. For example the darkest brown shown in the picture (055) actually comes off as a pretty bright ruby red, and the red in the picture (058) is a light orange/red. Three of the colors (054, 046, 050) are basically identical pink colors, and 056 & 052 are also identical orange colors. There are zero tans, taupes, or browns in the set which I was expecting based on the picture. There are two colors that I will never ever use because they are bright orange which is not shown in the picture.Second main issue is with the wear. The description says they are waterproof but they smudge really easily. I was able to remove the liner by smudging it with my finger on accident. When I see "waterproof" on a cosmetic product I assume that it will only come off with make-up remover or a make-up wipe and that it won't smudge. The color really doesn't last very long at all when applied. I drank a glass of water and an hour later it was really faded. The pencil glides on really nice, its smooth and stays smooth after application but it needs a lot of touch ups throughout the day.I'm pretty disappointed because I can only really use one or two colors in this set (the darkest brown 055 for my ruby red lipstick, and the darkest pink 059 for my bright pink lipstick.) The other 10 colors are pretty much useless to me.With such a large variety of colors I was hoping to be able to use more of the colors to match what I have already.

I was disappointed when I tried to use the brown pencil and the color was more of a maroon than brown. Also, the caps on the pencil are very unstable they kept falling off even when it was in the box. For the price of them, you would think the colors would match. Don't waste your money.

The lip liner was easy to put on and had a nice matte finish. The liner was actually BRIGHTER in some cases, but on the others the finish was mostly lighter. I would definitely recommend it and will use it as much as I so please. The package actually came much earlier than I expected it to come, which was a major plus.