Maison Close: Season 2 [Blu-ray]
N**E
....No Season Three?
Wow! This is the first french TV series I have watched. Having been blown away by the first season, I couldn't wait for the shenanigans in this season and to see who takes over the Paradis. Hortense(sp?) really grew at the beginning of this season - a time where the plot seemed to be moving quite slowly, yet just intriguing and visually stunning enough to continue. The middle of this series forwards was juicy, beautifully french and really showed the various "sides" with their teeth gritted and using every bit of intelligence and risk they had. I am so sad to see there's no Season three.
I**Z
fabulous series
I only wish the subtitles were a little bigger! I only have a little screen. Great storylines in series 1& 2...amazing characters portrayed with depth. I actually love the juxtaposition of the fin de siecle and modern music...and its not all modern. The costumes are just gorgeous. Given that it is set in a brothel there is a lot less of the sex scenes than you would think, well done for getting the balance right.
S**D
An interesting second season, but not as good as the first.
This is the second season of the series, and it takes place about a year after the events of season one ended. Most of the same cast return, and the series continues to be about the goings-on at a brothel in Paris in the 1870's.The series starts with the women who live and work at the brothel having taken over the running of things, and governing themselves. But events conspire against these women, so they find themselves having to have 'protection'. The men who enact this protection are a gang of criminals, and this second season closely follows the activities of this gang.It's not as good as season one. The show, at this point, lacks originality and the storyline is weaker. Nonetheless, it's still a fascinating series, and I enjoyed watching how these women struggled to retain some control over their lives.This Blu-ray offers excellent picture and sound quality. The show is in French (with English sub-titles).
A**E
Excellent!!!!!!!!!!
An absolutely superb drama ,'lost' because it's a foreign language with subtitles. Do NOT be put off by this - it is brilliant (do not watch if at all prudish - it is set in a brothel and not much is left to the imagination) but the storylines, the acting, the suspense is amazing!! Cannot recommend this and season one enough. Puts some British and American dramas to shame!! Please watch season one first as some of the storylines will require the background
K**Z
Dark passions in a complicated, brutal world.
Dark drama, dark passion, dark endings.Yes, the closing of the tale did seem a little rushed as it neatened threads, but hey, as it is so certainly the story of fast action lifestyles, to be true to that reality, the story could only close with intriguing haste.Acting superb, direction superb, production superb, script superb. Five Stars.
D**N
Series 1 is gruesome but interesting, series 2 less gruesome, less interesting...
It's true that series 2 isn't as good as series 1, but that pushes me below the level of wanting to keep watching. The first series is gruesome but interesting. It dwells on the horrors of being trapped into prostitution, which is a message for today as much as the 19th Century, and the rule throughout the first series is: however awful things are, they'll get much worse. It's horrifying to watch how some of the characters will, for the smallest of reasons, ruin another's life, or get them killed. But somehow it was almost believable, up until the last episode, where it appeared everything was on its characteristic path downwards, but then suddenly it was all OK now, everyone who survived was happy. I think this was partly because a hugely malignant character lurking in the shadows, about to bring everything crashing down, was suddenly forgotten about, which puzzled me.The second series is equally puzzling, in that it doesn't really follow on from the previous series - some things have reverted to how they were before the last episode of series 1, despite the everyone-is-happy feel to the first episode of series 2. (I don't want to say more, for fear of being accused of excessive spoilering....) Also, although series 1 was slow, full of scenes where not much happened, series 2 is more so. Lengthy shots of someone riding in a carriage in the same little street that all the other carriage rides have occurred in during the two series doesn't really add much to the plot or the viewer's enjoyment. The story line is even more fragmented, and seems to be moving more and more towards soap. The other frustration is things just aren't explained. People wander into the story, and wander out again. Things happen without any clear vision of what they are, or why they're in the series at all.Still, there's some really good acting, it looks good in a seedy sort of way. I agree the strange this-century music feels odd against the Victorian-era dress and manners, but I guess music of the time wouldn't fit the upbeat whorehouse idea. Having said that, some rather good unmodern choral stuff appeared in the second episode, so maybe this is changing for the better. But I'm not sure I'll be there to enjoy it. Having endured my way to the end of episode 2 of the second series, I don't feel there's enough I want to know about to keep watching.
K**D
A hasty wrap up to the series
The beginning of the season starts out very well with the introduction of Mosca and his crew, a strong mix of identifiable characters with their own quirks. It is directed in the style that is synonymous with the first season for the first few episodes, then gives way to characters doing things that viewers would find out of character...Towards the fifth episode the director takes a drastic change of style from a realistic insight into 19th century prostitution, to a Les Miserables blood-bath without taste or reason. There are too many themes explored and without a justifiable development of character.I recommend the season, but only the first half.
L**A
What's with the soundtrack!?! Such detail to ...
What's with the soundtrack!?! Such detail to set, costume, acting, plot....but a modern soundtrack that includes everything from jungle to pop? Really distracting and undermines the scenes
V**T
Série à voir
Série très sympaBons acteurs et histoire intéressante
P**N
Five Stars
Ok
F**E
A wrenching end to a top-notch production
Season 2 flashes forward a bit to 1873, still in the early days of the French Third Republic, when many were glad to be rid of the monarchy, yet others pined for its reestablishment. Much to the chagrin of Hortense, Le Paradis is now run by its proletariat residents, but it doesn't take long before the bordello is caught between the vice squad and a small band of hoodlums, leading to such scenarios as a picnic becoming a bloodbath.Season 2 features a magnificent reprisal of Rose by Jemima West, who now ranges from feisty newly literate Marxist to withdrawn lovestruck drug addict. In reviewing Season 1, I stated that somehow Maison Close "doesn't leave you in a pool of misery"; the same cannot be said for Season 2. Yet despite the emphatic tragedy of it all, Maison Close is well worth watching in its entirety, rivaling the best of dramas about the disenfranchised.There was industry chatter in 2012 about HBO picking up Maison Close for a remake; I can only hope that it didn't happen and that such a series doesn't come to fruition. This show about a sliver of French history was meant to be produced by the French, and it was done so here without room for improvement.
G**N
Realistic and well acted portrayal of life in a Parisian brothel in the 1800]s.
Set in a brothel, which translates from Maison Close, this is a very well acted and believable portrayal of life in a brothel in Paris in the 19th Century. It is not sensationalistic or titillating. It does develop the characters Vera, Hortense and Rose quite deeply and makes many of the cast members seem quite realistic and believable. I found the chapters held my attention quite well and I was disappointed when the series came to an end. I had come to know the main characters quite well.
V**O
Excellente série
Surprenante série on veut toujours savoir la suite. Le jeu des acteurs y est parfait. Une série à ne pas louper. Parfois un peu sombre mais réaliste (enfin je crois) de ces temps éloignés.
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
1 day ago