L'Oreal ParisCosmetics Voluminous Lash Paradise Liquid Eyeliner, Rose Gold, 0.05 Fluid Ounce

So. I have used this liner since it came on the market. It’s one of my go to favorites. However I ordered two because it’s impossible to find in stores. One of them was smooth and perfectly applied. The other container was clumped and totally dried out. I peeled the dried up liner off the brush applicator and found that the tube was totally empty. After shaking it and reinserting the clean brush, nothing came out. I stuck a q-tip wand (without the cotton on it), inside and it came out clean and dry. So I got one full tube and one totally dry and empty tube. So sad. Disappointing.

**EDITING THIS REVIEW DO NOT BUY** this product after TWO USES is completely dry, waste of money and can't return it. I suspect it's old, they shouldn't be allowed to sell this.I've always loved this liquid eyeliner, such a beautiful shimmer on it and glides on nice. It does tend to dry up quick in the bottle, but no worse than any other cheap liquid eyeliner on the market so I think it's a decent value. The condition it came in is questionable, you can see some weird specks on it. I suspect it's a discontinued eyeliner because I have trouble finding it now (shame L'Oreal shame) so I'm cautious buying this product thinking it might be from someone's old backstock. It seems like the bottle is still fresh enough, not dried up or anything, but L'Oreal I'm begging you start making this eyeliner again! 😭

I really like this product. I use the eyeliner alone or apply it above the black eyeliner I apply first and closest to my lashes. I only use on upper lid. (I find it hard to get locally ). Good thing I can purchase on Amazon

This is actually rose gold and I love it. It goes on pigmented, I mean it's a really light color to begin with, I really enjoy sticking it in my inner corner for a beautiful popof brightness. I have workall along my lashine as a liner and it's pretty, due to it being a soft rose gold, it's something I use for soft looks it have used on darker Shadow and did get a really pretty opaque liner still. Versatile and pretty. Unique to my collection and affordable. No complaints at all. Still hasn't dried out on me and I purchased this a while ago now. I will buy again, definitely.

I have been using this since 90’s. Quality definitely changed. I have been ordering it, since it’s cheaper than in local stores, but quality or storing of this item is incorrect. Every time I use it, it leaves flakes on my eyelids. When I apply it, or when I remove it.

When I shake the container I can get some eyeliner on the brush but it doesn’t seem full enough for a new container.

I normally don't use liquid liners, I tend to stick with Gel line or felt to plummets with a fine tip but I've always liked the intensity of liquid liners and this has an ideal brush for precision lining and easily doing a winged look. The brush is thin ending in Very pointy, fine top with a firmness that doesn't allow it to apply everywhere. Must give about 60 seconds to dry before touching or applying other eye products so not to mess up your hard work. What I love the most is that when it dries, it maintains that intense, almost wet look. So glad to have it on Subscribe and Save

Last one I got was empty and dried up, after reaching out I got my money back